Lower-powered "carry" ammo

  • 963 Views
  • Last Post 02 October 2019
M3 Mitch posted this 18 July 2019

Just a general question.  Particularly for someone who is not a shooting enthusiast but needs a carry gat - probably a revolver - would it be nuts to consider for example 148 grain wadcutters in a .38 Special?  For someone who might well be shooting inside their own house, and who is not particularly hardened to recoil (I am thinking about my little sister, to be specific).  I have heard that the wadcutters "punch well above their weight" - but on the other hand if somebody comes into the house uninvited with bad intent, there certainly is a school of thought to hit them as hard as you can.

Related question- just picked up a S&W lightweight M39 with 3" barrel, 5-shot .44 Special.  In the same vein would I be nuts to load it for carry or to put on the night stand with something like Black Hills "Cowboy" ammo - a cast flat point 210 grain at nominal 700 fps - idea being again ranges will be short, the gun is light and short barreled, have not shot it yet but imagine it recoils pretty vigorously, and with that 3" barrel the flash and blast are expected to be pretty impressive.  But there are considerably more powerful loads like just for example Winchester Silvertips available. 

I already have my ideas that neither above scenario is nuts, but, if I am inclined to take a bad road here, so to speak, maybe you guys can talk me out of it. 

Attached Files

Order By: Standard | Newest | Votes
M3 Mitch posted this 02 October 2019

About 40 years ago was "hard after" handgun hunting Ghogs. Bought an 8" Python hunter. Did right much killing,and while accuracy with JHP's was very good. Expansion wasn't. I'd prop up freshly killed hogs and test for expansion..... am talking fullhouse 158 g magnum loadings. There wasn't a whole lot to it. The HP would fill up with tissue and then act like a RN and more or less pencil through. Started using cast. A good,very sharply "filled out" SWC ended up what I settled on. Then it became and issue of that particular firearm/mould as to which was more accurate. The point is,accuracy,velocity,and the ability to control the recoil plays as big of role.... and in some cases,moreso than the actual bullet. Sharpness (mould fillout),can not be overstated. Good luck with your project.
So, you found a difference in stopping power between well-filled out bullets and those with slightly rounded edges?  I have not heard that before.  Can you expand on what you wrote?

 

Attached Files

M3 Mitch posted this 02 October 2019

I finally figured out exactly what the 5-shot S&W I bought is - it is an M396 "Night Guard", and the tritium front  sight, and fixed rear sight that is installed in a frame that would hold an adjustable sight actually came on it from the factory.  They looked like aftermarket sights, and to an extent that is true, S&W bought these from Cylinder and Slide, the rear being their "extreme duty" offering. According to Glen Fryxell, this gun is intended to be used with bullets more like 200 grains than the usual 250 that the .44 Special is loaded for to use in bigger gats:  http://www.lasc.us/Fryxell44SpecialRevisited.htm

Attached Files

M3 Mitch posted this 06 August 2019

Looking at the Black Hills "Cowboy" ammo, it appears to have a Lyman 429215 bullet, which is a 210 grain bullet, and Starline brass.  No idea what powder, but claimed velocity is 800 FPS. 

Need to head to the range and see how it shoots.  Even more need to find time to do some casting and loading myself. 

Attached Files

Shopdog posted this 31 July 2019

About 40 years ago was "hard after" handgun hunting Ghogs. Bought an 8" Python hunter. Did right much killing,and while accuracy with JHP's was very good. Expansion wasn't. I'd prop up freshly killed hogs and test for expansion..... am talking fullhouse 158 g magnum loadings. There wasn't a whole lot to it. The HP would fill up with tissue and then act like a RN and more or less pencil through. Started using cast. A good,very sharply "filled out" SWC ended up what I settled on. Then it became and issue of that particular firearm/mould as to which was more accurate.

The point is,accuracy,velocity,and the ability to control the recoil plays as big of role.... and in some cases,moreso than the actual bullet. Sharpness (mould fillout),can not be overstated. Good luck with your project.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • LouisianaMan
BigMan54 posted this 31 July 2019

Pretty fascinating stuff.

I use a Ruger Service-Six .357Mag with a 3" bbl as my Bedside Handgun. I load it with factory Hornady .38Spl 158gr HP's, simply because it's the freshest factory ammo I have. Both My Girls can shoot it with no problem. Pachmayr's help.

Mitch, you're welcome for the Black Hills .44Spl Cowboy Load. The Buyer at Turners, sent Jeff Hoffman to see me about 25-27yrs ago, about Loads for Cowboy Shooting. I gave Him a box of My .44Spl loads that I used in My Colts & Charter Arms old Bulldog. 210gr FP over 4.0grs of the then New TiteGroup.

Loads for .38Spl & .45Colt too. But the .45Colt didn't seem to have  been used. 

I know that .357Mag Revolver isn't a 5shot .38spl but I don't want to lose either of My Little Colts if I do have to use it.  Why limit yourself to 5, when 6 are available. And I have a cheap Mossberg PG pump shotgun in the closet, that only I can get to. Why waste an 870, when the Mossberg will serve. And yes I've put a couple of boxes of shells thru it. The Super Light 7/8oz -  2 1/2DE. 

I won't use Handloads because I live in Los Angeles County. I know the District Attorney Office has a habit of grinding people who defend themselves in the Own Homes. No need to give them an excuse to grind harder because I used Handloads.

As far as Cowboy Loads go, I know some gamers that use a 90gr bullet in .38Spl and 160-165gr bullet in .45Colt.  The bullets are moving about 550-650fps. Anything to gain an edge.  

Long time Caster/Reloader, Getting back into it after almost 10yrs. Life Member NRA 40+yrs, Life S.A.S.S. #375. Does this mean a description of me as a fumble-fingered knuckle-draggin' baboon. I also drool in my sleep. I firmly believe that true happiness is a warm gun. Did I mention how much I HATE auto-correct on this blasted tablet.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • LouisianaMan
Brodie posted this 31 July 2019

I have learned (to my detriment) that Lawyers will say anything that suits them.  Truth is definitely optional and may be discarded at will. 

I have been told that the safest thing to carry is what your local PD uses, ammo and weapon.  Other than that the only other option would be to shoot the lawyer first.  THe legal beagle being the most dangerous thing around.

B.E.Brickey

Attached Files

harleyrock posted this 30 July 2019

I know that most of us on this forum load our own ammo with bullets we have cast ourselves, but gun instructor and author Massad Ayoob in his book "Deadly Force" recommends the use of factory ammunition for self defense because of the potential of a civil suit following a shooting.  Wily plaintiff's lawyers make issue of "gun nuts" making their own "excessively deadly" killer ammo.

I use the Ruger ARX ammo with the Polycase polymer/copper composite bullet in my .45 ACP Springfield XDS.  The 118 gr bullet at 1307 fps should get the job done without over penetration.

Lifetime NRA since 1956, NRA Benefactor, USN Member, CBA Member

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
M3 Mitch posted this 30 July 2019

Yeah, Black Hills has cowboy ammo in .44 Russian as well.  Same bullet as the Special, shorter case, 650 FPS.  It's an option for a further reduction in blast and recoil if I think it's still a bit much.  I have not shot any of the Special ammo, but expect it to be "just what the doctor ordered" so to speak.

In my experience, shorter brass gives less accuracy.  This is very pronounced with a .32 S&W short in a Long chamber, made more obvious by how well the Longs generally shoot.  A .44 Russian in a .44 Special chamber would not be that far short of the leade, so would probably shoot at least OK.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • LouisianaMan
bdrake71 posted this 30 July 2019

Look up the 44 Russian cartridge.  It was parent cartridge of the 44 Special.  It's the grandfather of the 44 Magnum.
http://www.sixguns.com/tests/tt44russ.htm, John Taffin did a good piece about the cartridge and provided smokeless load data.

Starline sells the modern designed brass which is actually head-stamped as .44 RUSSIAN  or you could cutdown 44 Magnum or 44 Special cases and then inside ream the shortened case for proper bullet tension without resizing the bullet down during the seating stage. 44 Russian reloading dies are available from RCBS and LEE.  I would recommend the LEE if you don't want to have to adjust the dies every time whenever you switch between cartridges when reloading or break the bank.

To quote Taffin:

"The original Blackpowder load 23gr of FFg was 750fps with a 246gr Roundnose was with the original balloonhead cases.  
Taffin-Recommended Modern loads with Starline Brass are 6gr of Unique (890fps) or 6.0 grains of Unique (890 feet per second) and 6.0 grains of WW231 (900 feet per second). Notice again these all rank right with today's defensive loadings. Speer's swaged lead 240 grain semi-wadcutter is an excellent utility bullet when seated over 6.0 grains of Unique for 950 feet per second."

Taffin also provides load date for bullets ranging from 190gr to 246gr (975 to 725 ft per second) so you could possibly use the loads in your .44 Special Revolver for low recoil but effective home defense bullets.  The 44 Russian cartridge has a capacity of 27gr of water in comparison to the 44 Special's 33.5gr of internal volume so you could easily work up a 44 Special load with the 44 Russian load data.

Or you could just buy the 44 Russian dies and ready made brass

Bruce


Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • LouisianaMan
shjoe posted this 27 July 2019

sounds like a valid plan, M3 mitch. I think the 44 spl is currently underrated. should do a fine job of "repelling boarders" and give you some fired cases to reload.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • LouisianaMan
  • DBW
M3 Mitch posted this 25 July 2019

Well, FWIW, that S&W M39 went on nightstand duty yesterday evening, loaded with the Black Hills "Cowboy" ammo.  I got some Silvertips at the same time, but for the reasons discussed previously I think the lower powered ammo will be more than sufficient if I have to "repel boarders". 

The Black Hills ammo is the first of that brand I have seen myself.  I am very impressed with it, loaded in Starline brass, with a cast bullet (I can see the mold parting line, but barely), it is very close to what I would load myself if I could find the time - well, I will find the time but this is my first and so far only .44 Special (got a "Dirty Harry" M29 and have had that for some time, but this is the first Special) so I didn't have any brass on hand.  I wanted to skip to the front of the line so to speak and be able to try this thing out, for something less than say 50 cents a round.  I won't recommend this stuff till I at least shoot a few rounds, but, it certainly seems promising as a way to shoot sooner on a caliber you have not been using.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • LouisianaMan
shjoe posted this 21 July 2019

great information gentlemen. the only time I felt under gunned was during an investigation where the uniform was business casual. with the exception of my wallet id, I carried a light weight 38 snub nose in an ankle rig. better to have it and not need it. the work and the job was very routine, but it is what you unsuspectingly step in that livens things up. visited a guy right address, but wrong adjacent town. place was a dump. I  stepped on a loose board down the tenement hall way and the hall way lights went out. I slowly back tracked out of that hall way with 5 shot 38 snubby in hand. not enough gun if things had rapidly turned into cacalella. a compact 9mm with 2 extra mags went with me next time.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • LouisianaMan
Brodie posted this 20 July 2019

There are people down here who think that the Elk got armor plated 20 or so years ago.  But  I dropped a big cow last fall with a 7x57 Mauser with one shot.  Like the Game Warden told me: " They kill them up here all the time with a 22rf.".

B.E.Brickey

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • LouisianaMan
RicinYakima posted this 20 July 2019

Always about shot placement and penetration.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • TRKakaCatWhisperer
Brodie posted this 19 July 2019

When High Standard brought out their 22 wmr Derringer my friend Ed Davenport (now deceased) took one and tried it on a police issue soft vest (no plate).  The round zipped right through the "bullet proof " vest.  Ed also tried some of the, then new, CCI Minimags in 22rf.  Those rounds also zipped right through the "bullet proof" vest.  Ed did this research as part of his job as Armorer for the LBPD Swat team.  Ed was not too happy about the results when he told me about the tests.  Ed had worn one of those vest since they first came out.

There was also a story related by a Long Beach Sargent (who shall remain nameless).  According to the Sargent a lady of "negotiable virtue" was plying her trade on Long Beach Blvd in the neighboring city of Compton when an Individual approached her and demanded that she give him her purse.  She said: "Can I just give you my wallet?". The robber replied in the affirmative.  Our Negotiable Virtue lady then took out her High Standard double barreled derringer and shot him in the chest.  The bullet went through the Sternum, through the Heart and removed a vertebrae from his spine.  The robber was dead when he hit the ground.  According to my source the investigating officer reloaded her weapon and returned it to her. 

B.E.Brickey

Attached Files

RicinYakima posted this 18 July 2019

 When I was doing undercover drug work in 1970, I had a Hi-Standard over/under .22 Magnum DAO in each front pocket of my stripped bell bottoms. Tie-dyed T-shirt covered down to mid-thigh.  Never felt unarmed, but college drug dealers were not the violent gangs like we have today.

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • LouisianaMan
beagle6 posted this 18 July 2019

Ed

I tend to agree with you. Bill Jordan made the comment in his book, "No Second Place Winner". He was chief firearms instructor for the Border Patrol,and a combat veteran. I have to take him seriously, but I'm keeping my wadcutters too

beagle6

Attached Files

  • Liked by
  • M3 Mitch
  • LouisianaMan
Ed Harris posted this 18 July 2019

A .22 WMR fired from a concealable handgun has about the same energy as standard velocity .22 LR fired from a sporting-length rifle.  Bullets which are fragile enough to expand penetrate poorly.  This link has data from most of the current brands.  I would not give up my .38 snub or .380 ACP:

https://www.americanrifleman.org/articles/2015/6/8/the-22-magnum-for-self-defense/

 

73 de KE4SKY In Home Mix We Trust From the Home of Ed's Red in "Almost Heaven" West Virginia

Attached Files

beagle6 posted this 18 July 2019

Over the last several years I taught several women to shoot who did not have enough strength to pull back the slide on a 380. much less a 9mm. Sometimes a revolver is the best answer. FWIW, Bill Jordan thought that the 22 Magnum Rimfire was a wicked round out of a revolver.

beagle6

Attached Files

Ed Harris posted this 18 July 2019

A "full-charge" wadcutter load should perform better than the midrange target wadcutter load and is my preferred carry in snubbies.  The factory target ammo is more manageable in the very light Airweight guns.  Some gel tests from various blogs give penetration data which may be helpful if you are ever attacked by The Jello Man.

http://mousegunaddict.blogspot.com/2014/01/federal-gold-medal-match-38-special.html

https:/s.brianenos.com/topic/244329-38-wadcutters-for-self-defense/

https://www.luckygunner.com/lounge/wadcutter-ammo-self-defense/

In the 1970s both Remington at Bridgeport, and Winchester at New Haven, CT loaded "full charge" wadcutters, originally intended as training and practice ammunition by the NYPD. The rationale, according to Frank McGee who headed the firearms unit back in the day, was that they didn't want cops practicing with "light target loads" but wanted the wadcutter bullet assembled into the case using the same powder charge then common for 158-grain LRN service ammo, so that the recoil would be similar. Velocity was about 800 fps from a 4" S&W Model 10 or Colt Police Positive, blue square-butt .38 Special "cop gun" as then issued.

The story told to me by Bill Allard, was that Jim Cirillo and others in the Stakeout Unit realized a good thing when they saw it and took this new practice ammo to the street, where it performed better than the "official" LRN service ammo. When questioned by the shooting review board, to a man they stuck with their story, "we came from the range and the wadcutter ammo was what we had with us" and the rest is history.

Buffalo Bore loads a similar non+P round today. 

73 de KE4SKY In Home Mix We Trust From the Home of Ed's Red in "Almost Heaven" West Virginia

Attached Files

Show More Posts
Close